home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text>
- <title>
- (Jan. 13, 1992) Surge to The Right
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1992
- Jan. 13, 1992 The Recession:How Bad Is It?
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- WORLD, Page 22
- EUROPE
- Surge to The Right
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>From the Atlantic to the Urals, politicians stir fear and
- loathing of dark-skinned immigrants
- </p>
- <p>By George J. Church--Reported by James L. Graff/Vienna,
- Margot Hornblower/Paris and Ann M. Simmons/Moscow
- </p>
- <p> They range from jackbooted skinhead youths assaulting
- foreigners in Germany to sedately dressed middle-aged couples
- dining off lace tablecloths at a banquet outside Amiens--under
- a poster urging the eviction of immigrants from France. Their
- leaders include old nobility, yuppie types, an ex-paratrooper
- who boasts of being born in a house with a dirt floor, and
- former communists. But whatever their appearance or origin, the
- far-right-wingers who are emerging across the European continent
- share an alarming attitude, if not exactly an ideology: a
- virulent nationalism expressed mainly as raw hatred of
- foreigners, particularly immigrants. They also share momentum:
- West and East, their influence is on the rise.
- </p>
- <p> That might seem paradoxical. In western Europe the
- headlined trend is toward unprecedented economic and even
- political unity. The fear of Bolshevism that played so great a
- role in prompting the growth of European fascism between the two
- world wars has virtually disappeared with the disintegration of
- the Soviet empire in the East.
- </p>
- <p> But in the former communist satellite nations, the red
- downfall has lifted the lid off long-suppressed ethnic
- nationalism, while prompting some people with no tradition of
- democracy to look for an alternative form of "strong"
- government. In the West, right-wing movements have inherited
- some of the generalized protest vote that used to go communist.
- Jean-Marie Le Pen's National Front does well these days in the
- industrial suburbs of Paris that were long known as the Red
- Belt.
- </p>
- <p> East and West, economic distress is also spurring the
- rightist revival. In the East, the breakdown of command
- economies has led to chaos and suffering that the painful birth
- of free markets has not yet relieved. Western Europe, though far
- more prosperous, nonetheless has been experiencing some of its
- highest unemployment rates since World War II. It has been easy
- for demagogues to blame immigrants who snatch away the jobs of
- the native-born--though that happens far more often in
- right-wing mythology than in reality. The movement toward west
- European integration has also provoked a nationalist backlash
- in some countries. France's Le Pen lately has been drawing
- cheers by sneering at unity-advocating "federasts."
- </p>
- <p> The power of the far right should not be exaggerated. In
- no European country is an extremist party close to taking
- power. Only in Austria, and possibly France, does it even have
- an outside chance of muscling its way into a government
- coalition. On the other hand, the rightists in some countries
- are exercising more influence on mainstream politicians and
- parties than their vote counts might indicate.
- </p>
- <p> And rightist sentiment is popping up in some unexpected
- places. In Belgium the anti-immigrant Vlaams Blok party
- increased its representation from two to 12 seats in November's
- parliamentary elections. Sweden, long considered the socialist's
- dream of the earthly paradise, gave its Social Democrats their
- worst electoral defeat in 60 years in 1991. The European
- Community warned at its Maastricht summit in December "that
- manifestations of racism and xenophobia are steadily growing in
- Europe."
- </p>
- <p> A rundown on that growth, from the Atlantic to the Urals:
- </p>
- <p> FRANCE. The right-wing National Front, according to a
- mid-December poll, would win about 15% of the vote if
- parliamentary elections were held today. That is only slightly
- above what Le Pen personally polled in the 1988 presidential
- election. But the mainstream parties have kept him from making
- further inroads only by echoing some of his hostility to
- immigrants, especially dark-skinned Muslim Arabs and Africans.
- Paris Mayor Jacques Chirac has called for a moratorium on
- allowing immigrants' families to join them and suggested denying
- welfare payments to residents of non-French ancestry; former
- President Valery Giscard d'Estaing has hinted at refusing
- automatic citizenship to French-born children of immigrants. All
- three ideas came straight out of Le Pen's platform. Even
- Socialist President Francois Mitterrand once declared that
- France had passed "the threshold of tolerance" in absorbing
- African and Arab immigrants.
- </p>
- <p> Still, nobody can match Le Pen in playing on the
- resentment of petits blancs (poor whites) toward the immigrants.
- Now he is appealing to other kinds of discontent. He is making
- a strong pitch to farmers worried that European integration will
- strip away their accustomed subsidies, and is even putting out
- feelers to ecological and animal-rights activists, who also have
- been gaining among voters bored with the mainstream parties. It
- is just conceivable that if the vote in the 1993 legislative
- elections splinters widely, a coalition strong enough to form
- a government could be put together only by including Le Pen.
- </p>
- <p> ITALY. Senator Umberto Bossi, a onetime leftist, hit the
- big time in the spring of 1990 when his ultra-conservative
- Lombard League won enough votes in industrial northern Italy to
- become the second biggest party in the region. As leftist views
- have gone out of style, discontented voters are turning to the
- right to express their bitter disaffection with the government
- in Rome. In a November election in the city of Brescia, the
- league polled 24.4% to edge out the Christian Democrats for No.
- 1. In the next general elections, which could come as early as
- this spring, the league plans to run candidates for Parliament
- throughout Italy; some polls indicate that the league and
- like-minded groups could collect 21% of the vote.
- </p>
- <p> That might seem surprising, since Bossi's league
- originated as a separatist group urging the north to secede from
- a central government that was bleeding it for the sake of the
- poorer south. But voters up and down the peninsula are attracted
- by the league's message of opposition to corruption and
- confusion in high places, to government taxation and red tape,
- and to every social ill from joblessness and drug peddling to
- immigration. Bossi and some of his allies have voiced views
- toward dark-skinned immigrants that are as racist as any in
- Europe.
- </p>
- <p> GERMANY. Alienated youths known as skinheads have shown
- terrifying power to unleash violence against foreigners,
- especially in what was formerly East Germany. There the populace
- went from Nazi to communist totalitarianism without any
- democratic interval. So far, unification has brought economic
- instability rather than prosperity and has wiped out the
- state-subsidized clubs that used to keep the young off the
- streets.
- </p>
- <p> With little else to do, many have turned to random--and
- racially motivated--violence. The national government counted
- 2,074 crimes motivated by hatred of foreigners in 1991, vs. only
- 246 in 1990. A Mozambican immigrant was thrown out of a trolley
- car to his death in Dresden; a Vietnamese was stabbed nearly to
- death in Leipzig; some Soviet children who survived the
- Chernobyl nuclear accident and were convalescing in a special
- children's home in Zittau, 150 miles south of Berlin, were
- assailed by a gang of stone-throwing drunks who shouted, "Jews,
- die!"
- </p>
- <p> But the right's ability to make noise far exceeds its
- power to win votes. Unification has actually undercut the
- electoral appeal of right-wing parties. The biggest, Die
- Republikaner, won 7.5% of the vote in West Berlin in 1989 but
- polled only 2.1% in the nationwide Bundestag elections in 1990.
- Its adherents have no seats in parliament or in any state
- legislatures. That could change if the rightists can find a
- charismatic leader; so far, it has none.
- </p>
- <p> AUSTRIA. Exactly the opposite is true here, where Jorg
- Haider, an articulate young (43) David Duke look-alike, is
- smooth enough to be described as a "yuppie fascist." Last summer
- he declared that the Nazis "had a proper employment policy in
- the Third Reich," then had to resign his provincial governorship
- in the protest that ensued. But he has led his Austrian Freedom
- Party to a higher share of the vote in 13 straight provincial
- and national elections, and in November the party won a
- startling 23% of the ballots in staunchly Socialist Vienna. It
- just might poll enough in the next national elections in 1994
- to force Haider's inclusion in a government coalition.
- </p>
- <p> The party pushes some respectable causes: deregulation of
- industry and an end to tenure for government bureaucrats. But
- as everywhere else in Europe its main appeal is to hostility
- against immigrants. Freedom Party posters in the capital,
- pandering to a fear that immigrants are prone to crime,
- exhorted, DON'T TURN VIENNA INTO CHICAGO. Such fears seem more
- than passing strange. Almost 510,000 registered foreigners
- represent 6.5% of the total Austrian population; 100,000 more
- are thought to have entered the country illegally. But Austria
- has prospered despite the influx. Through most of the 1980s, it
- boasted the lowest unemployment rate in Europe outside tiny
- Luxembourg. Since the immigrants come mostly from
- Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Yugoslavia, they "aren't greatly
- different in cultural and religious terms" from native
- Austrians, says political scientist Anton Pelinka. That they
- should nevertheless encounter such strong resentment, he says,
- "doesn't bode well for a united Europe."
- </p>
- <p> EASTERN EUROPE. While Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia
- strive more or less successfully to replace communism with
- Western-style democracy, in other former Soviet satellites the
- alternative to red rule seems to be a mystic nationalism based
- on blood and soil. That holds particularly true for the main
- antagonists in the Yugoslav civil war. Serbian President
- Slobodan Milosevic, still nominally a socialist, has led his
- people to war in the name of a virulent ethnic nationalism that
- has nothing in common with the international brotherhood of
- workers to which he once professed allegiance. For his major
- opponent, Croatian President Franjo Tudjman, democratic
- principles merely temper a style reminiscent of a Latin American
- caudillo, complete with ceremonial-sashed portrait displayed in
- all police stations and paternalistic rhetoric reminiscent of
- Peron or Pinochet. Yet his major internal opposition comes from
- an even more extreme group: the Croatian Party of Rights, which
- unabashedly honors the memory of the fascist, Hitler-backed
- state that flourished briefly during World War II.
- </p>
- <p> In Romania several extreme nationalist parties blame
- ethnic minorities--Hungarians, Jews and gypsies--for the
- country's severe economic troubles. Though these parties do not
- yet exercise any real power, President Ion Iliescu has felt
- obliged to court their support.
- </p>
- <p> RUSSIA. "Since 1917 we have been living under the
- occupation of Jewish fascists," says Valeri Yemelyanov, leader
- of one of several so-called patriotic groups. His view is
- totally false: though some leaders of the Bolshevik Revolution
- were Jewish, Joseph Stalin and his successors practiced
- anti-Semitism almost as zealously as the czars. No matter: many
- Russians are looking for someone to blame for the shortages and
- hunger that have followed the collapse of communism, and some
- are finding that all-purpose, historic scapegoat, the Jew.
- Others focus on the Central Asians and residents of the Caucasus
- area who sell many of the scarce meats and vegetables that turn
- up in Moscow farm markets, sometimes at exorbitant prices.
- </p>
- <p> These hatreds are harnessed by a variety of movements,
- many of them grouped under an umbrella organization called
- Pamyat, which preaches a sacred nationalism looking toward an
- authoritarian Russia purged of all foreign influences. The
- leader of one such group, Vladimir Zhirinovsky, though widely
- regarded as a clown, placed third in a field of seven in the
- Russian presidential election last June--and that was before
- the political disintegration and economic collapse had reached
- anything like their present stage.
- </p>
- <p> For all that, the continent-wide rise of the right is more
- a nagging worry than an imminent danger. Even in France or
- Austria, where right-wing attitudes have enflamed the public
- debate, heavy majorities of voters want no part of the right as
- ruler. But the right has shown enough strength in enough places
- so that it cannot be ignored. Democratic governments can put it
- down, but only if they demonstrate the strength to bring about
- renewed prosperity and the ability to offer a vision more
- compelling than the right's mean and narrow--but unfortunately
- still attractive--nationalism of blood and soil.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-